Politics with Marc Ambinder

« Torture Memos: The Lawyers Aren't Immune | Main | 2nd 100 Days Watch: Budget Discipline, National Service »

Apr 21 2009, 2:00 pm

Lieberman Exercises Freedom Of Speech

In fairness, Joe Lieberman (I-CT) was asked for his opinion by Fox News's Greta Van Susteren in an interview yesterday; his opinion just happened to contradict what the Obama administration had done last Thursday--namely, to release Bush-administration legal memos supporting torture. (Lieberman retained his chairmanship of the Senate Homeland Security Committee after the 2008 election, in which he supported his longtime friend John McCain, despite an outcry from Senate Democrats who thought he should be removed, possibly even from the Democratic caucus, for backing McCain and questioning Obama's patriotism.)

Here's what Lieberman said on Fox:

VAN SUSTEREN: Again, the whole business about the torture memos being released by the Obama administration -- good idea or bad idea?

LIEBERMAN: I thought release of the memos was a bad idea.

The President of the United States as the commander in chief has the right to decide what kinds of tactics he wants to use with detainees who we believe are associated with terrorism and what kinds he does not want to use. Congress legislated on that. I was a cosponsor with Senator McCain of the anti-torture provisions we put into law.

But once you start to take internal memos that have been designated as top secret --
Lieberman has praised Obama since the election and, in the same interview yesterday, supported Obama's initial response to Mexican drug violence. Obama, one could argue, saved Lieberman from castigation by reportedly telling Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid he wasn't interested in seeing the former Democratic VP nominee punished, sending a message that campaign bygones were bygones, and that Lieberman was entitled to his freedom of speech without retribution. Looks as if Lieberman is taking that principle to the bank and exercising the freedom Obama (or the Constitution--whichever) bestowed.

Comments (4)

Buzz Feedback

So, Joe Lieberman is saying, "Look at me!" What's newsworthy about that?

notavailable

Lieberman has every right to speak his mind.

That said I look forward to the 2010 when he will likely lose his importance, and 2012 when he will likely lose his seat.


The implication of this missive is that, in gratitude to Obama, one should expect Lieberman to back him on any issue, regardless of his own convictions.

Since Lieberman has always agreed with his Democratic colleagues on the majority of issues -- economic, social, environmental, etc. -- it is hardly surprising that he has found reason to praise the President in the last few months.

Obviously when it comes to national security issues he has long differed with most Democrats. So this is entirely consistent, and precisely what would be expected.

But leave it to the contemptuous to ascribe expediency to Lieberman at every turn -- even as he continues to embrace principle.

Mike,

It is so refreshing to read an intelligent response. I agree with you completely and would add, that it is so unusal to have a Senator stick by his convictions, no matter what, that we all should be celebrating Lieberman.


By the way, I think notavailable is wrong, I believe Lieberman will continue to be elected a Senator, as long as he decides to serve. I think his constituents enjoy having an honest politician represent them, even they don't agree with him all of the time.