The Atlantic Home

Is it at all possible that the election wasn't rigged, given that evidence supporting this is scant and inferential? No one's asking this question, and it seems an obvious one in light of Venezuela in 2004. It hasn't prove difficult for an opposition party in a country governed by someone the West generally doesn't like to invent a convincing case for fraud. It's particularly easy in cases where information is at a premium, which was the case in Venezuela also.

The converse to this is that evidence for fraud is overlooked when it's presented by oppositions that we don't prefer - Mexico 2006.

The solution in Iran isn't to give what might be a small minority the moral support to be slaughtered (because we likely don't have the courage to provide physical support to back it up). The best idea is to encourage a new election monitored by an impartial international agency; if it was really such a landslide, the results will be repeated and certified.

I hope that Moussavi's claim in absence of any evidence of a landslide on his part is right, but there's a strong case that the media in this case isn't being skeptical enough (when they aren't ignoring the story all together).