How optimistic are you that President Obama will sign health care reform legislation into law by the end of the year? If so, why? If not, why not?
« The Day In Politics, 7/8 | Main | Sanford Vs. The Polls »
Jul 9 2009, 6:28 am by Chris Good
Question Of The Day: Will Obama Sign Health Reform?
Comments (8)
| RSS ![]()
Today's Headlines From The Atlantic
Energy Oil on Ice
Will Greenland become the Nigeria of the Arctic?
books The Pity of War
Is leading your own troops to slaughter ever OK?
moving pictures Retching With the Stars
The addictive appeal of Dr. Drew
- Problems With 'Precious'
- If Abbas Quits, Are Peace Talks Doomed?
- When a Muslim-American Killer Is in The News
VOICES
Mental Health Break 11.7.09 4:20 P.M.
Worst. Talking Point. Ever. 11.6.09 3:23 P.M.
Question Of The Weekend: The House Vote 11.7.09 8:30 A.M.
They Always Remember You 11.6.09 3:00 P.M.
In defense of the TSA 11.7.09 2:25 P.M.
The Origins of Israels Tech Miracle 11.5.09 8:57 A.M.
Why Democrats are...smiling? 11.6.09 1:53 A.M.
Recent posts by Marc Ambinder
- The Election Line: 2:00 pm ET Update
- Think Again: Breaking Through The Election Spin
- The Most Popular 2009 Election Video Is Phat
- So Many Assumptions, So Little Time
- Why Are Democrats Afraid Of The Debt?
Recent posts by Chris Good
Weekly
Author
- Jodie Allen and Richard Auxier
- Adam Minter
- Andrew Sullivan
- Bob Cohn
- Scott Bland and Ronald Brownstein
- Benjamin Lockwood
- Conor Clarke
- Clive Crook
- Chris Geidner
- Chris Good
- Cameron Joseph
- Clement Tan
- Chris VanBuren
- D.B. Grady
- Daniella De Franco
- Daniel Indiviglio
- Derek Thompson
- Gautham Nagesh
- Gautham Nagesh
- James Fallows
- James Bennet
- James Gibney
- Joshua Green
- Jeannette Lee
- Jenny Merkin
- Justin Miller
- James Warren
- Jim Kessler and Anne Kim
- Kerry Golds
- Katharine Rust
- Marc Ambinder
- Matthew Cooper
- Max Fisher
- Mara Gay
- Michael Kinsley
- Megan McArdle
- Nicole Allan
- Rachael Brown
- Ross Douthat
- Regina Herzlinger
- Ronald Brownstein
- Reihan Salam
- Shane Harris
- Shauna Miller
- Staff
- Tali Yahalom
- Will DiNovi
Monthly
Category
- CBS News Politics
- Trippi
- FiveThirtyEight.com
- The Daily Beast
- Drudge Report
- Instapundit
- NJ's Political Stock Exchange
- Law: Executive Watch
- Steve Coll
- Politics: A-NES
- MSNBC's First Read
- Laura Rozen
- ProPublica
- The Fix
- Politico's Smith
- Shadow Government
- Dave Catanese's blog/KY3-TV
- Global Affairs
- Greg Sargent's TPMEC
- The Frontal Cortex
- 3 Quarks Daily
- Neurophilosophy
- Environment: Grist
- Overcoming Bias
- Pollster.com
- Radio Iowa (O. Kay!)
- A Daily Shot (and Chaser)
- The Cable
- Arms Control Wonk
- Nukes Of Hazard
- Mark Halperin's "The Page"
- Huffington Post Politics
- Fred Malek
- Nukes and Spooks
- Bob Bauer
- Hotline On Call
- The Stump
- NHNewslinks.com
- Prof. Dante Scala
- Robert Bluey
- NH2008.com
- Matt Lewis
- Patrick Ruffini
- CT Blog
- CQ's Jeff Stein
- Not Just Markos
- FAS Secrecy Blog
- The Buzz
- Wilshire And Washington
- Political Muscle
- Political Wire
- Arts and Letters Daily
- The Garance
- Wired's Danger Room
- Jake Tapper
- Pop Sugar
- Political Punch
- Greg Mankiw
- Captain's Quarters
- Marginal Revolution
- Mind Hacks
- Opinion Journal
- ARDA
- Virginia Postrel
- The Reality-Based Community
- Science Daily
- News @ Nature
- Retrospectacle
- Pharyngula
- The Airline Blog
- Cognitive Daily
- ThinkProgress
- Wonkette
- The Corner
- Clive Davis
- Kevin Drum
- Glenn Greenwald
- Intel Dump
- The Plank
- The Volokh Conspiracy
- Debka File
- Angry Asian Man
- AmericaBlog
- The Washington Note
- Obsidian Wings
- NYT's The Caucus
- Michael Barone
- SCOTUS Blog
- How Appealing
- Above The Law
- ACS Blog
- The Washington Independent
- Law Dork
- Ezra Klein
Home | Atlantic FAQ | Masthead | Site Guide | Subscribe | Subscriber Help
Atlantic Store | Educational Program | Jobs/Internships | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | Feedback | Advertise
Copyright © 2009 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.






I am not particularly optimistic because of the Senate.
Overall there is quite a bit of confusion, even for the really well informed, about what is actually happening with health care legislation. Confusion breeds pessimism, even if the pessimism isn't necessarily warranted. All I know is that the Obama Administration keeps making deals with hospitals and insurance companies. I don't think that those in the health care industry would be making these deals if they didn't think some type of reform was coming. Why be at the table if you thought nothing was going to happen? As long as the industry thinks something is going to happen, I’ll continue to guardedly optimistic.
Also, the democrats have really tethered themselves to enacting some type of health care reform. If they don't get something done voters will have little confidence in them in 2010. I’d like to believe that Senate Democrats aren’t that stupid. I’d like to, but they haven’t given me a lot of reason to, yet.
Optimistic? I'm terrified.
I am very optimisitc IN SPITE of the Senate. And for a very simple reason: the entire Democratic primary between Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama eventually boiled down to health care as their main difference and Hillary Clinton won the debate on points even if she lost the election. Beyond simply the democratic base; the entire nation has internalized the debate on health care and reached the Democratic Party's conclusion: we need real reform. It's why the choice of the public option has gained steam in the face of 1 million dollar a day lobbyists money being poured against it. It's why people want health care reform even as they fear the growing deficit.
The Democratic Party knows it needs real reform, the base demands a public option, and independents have signed on to reform.
It's going to get done at the end of the day IMO, it's gonna have a ground breaking public insurance option, and it's going to save a lot of Democrats in 2010 even as the job losses increase b/c Democrats can say accurately they inherited a bigger problem than they thought from Bush BUT they increased the social safety net so if you lost your job your family still has health care and unemployment insurance.
I'm terrified because the administration seems to think reform is expansion, and I'm worried there will be only window dressing reform (electronic records or preventative medicine) with massive expansion that will be too costly to maintain.
A bill will be signed for sure, simply because so many have so much at stake. It might not have a lot of things that most democrats want, and it might have some things that they don't.
I am optimistic a bill will be signed that will make things better, despite the senate.
But what I'd really like is universal health care, like they have in pretty much every other wealthy country. Until that happens, I don't think the cost of health care (which is 50% more per person than everywhere else in the world) will go down that much.
Something will be signed - I hope not but I am afraid that something will be signed. Hopefully it won't make everything that much worse.